How Did Darwinism Take Root in the Ottoman
Empire?
By the
early 19th century, Westernization had become the top trend among
the Ottoman intelligentsia and diplomats. First scientific and technological
developments, and then political and economic models of the Western world made
their way into the empire to renovate the Ottoman state system. Even the
Ottoman army went through a thorough reformation that included detailed changes
in uniforms and equipment.
Although
this Westernization trend was useful in some areas, it also negatively
influenced the social order and mindset of the Ottoman public. Many people
began to believe that the Western world was 'absolutely better' in everything,
including philosophy and science. Atheistic ideologies like materialism,
positivism and Darwinism, already prevalent in Europe, affected many Ottoman
intellectuals. As a result, many came to believe that being an atheist,
supporting unscientific claims of Darwin and having a materialist worldview
meant being modern and Western-like. Some politicians of the time built their
policies on social Darwinism, which claimed that only strong societies could
survive in the fight for life. Ultimately, this Darwinist trend that denied the
existence of God became the downfall of the Ottoman Empire. Starting in the
second half of the 19th century, materialist views of Ernst Haeckel,
Herbert Spencer, Auguste Comte etc. proliferated among some of the Ottoman
intellectuals. During this time, more than two hundred materialist and
Darwinist books were translated into Turkish and Arabic.
During
this time, materialist books were widely circulated at the Ottoman medical,
law, political science and military schools, which trained many officers and
administrators. A 19th-century traveler named Mac Farlane wrote what
he saw after he paid a visit to the medical school in the Ottoman Empire in
1847:
[Referring
to the medical library] It was long since I had seen such a collection of
downright materialism. ... A book was lying open on the divan. I took it up. It
was a copy of a recent Paris edition of the Atheist's manual, "Système de
la Nature", with the name of the Baron d'Holbach on the title-page as the
author. The volume had evidently been much used; many of the striking passages
had been marked, and especially those which mathematically demonstrated the
absurdity of believing in the existence of a God and the impossibility of believing
in the immortality of the soul.113 [Certainly, Almighty God is above such remarks]
In other
words, Darwinist thoughts that dragged students into atheism quickly
proliferated in the medical schools. Abdülaziz Khan ordered that Darwinist
education be stopped at once as soon as he ascended to the throne, and
dismissed from their duties those who were arguing in favor of a
Darwinist/materialist education.
Spread of the Theory of Evolution in the
Empire during the Reign of Sultan Abdul Hamid II
The Darwinist
indoctrination that came to a standstill during the reign of Sultan Abdülaziz
reached its height during the rule of Abdul Hamid II. Darwinist/materialist
papers, books and journals spread across the Empire's lands, and mostly in
Istanbul, Lebanon, Egypt, and Syria. Even more worryingly, Darwinism was
incorporated into the school curriculum in many places. Darwinist/materialist
officers that were removed from their duties by Abdülaziz were not only
reinstated, they were promoted to key positions in the Ministry of Education,
the State Publishing House and even to grand viziership.
Abdul
Hamid II himself ordered that 20,000 copies of the Hamidian Treatise by
Lebanese writer Husayn al-Jisr be printed and distributed in Istanbul. The book
was full of materialist and Darwinist claims and was intended to sow the seeds
of atheistic philosophy in Ottoman society. Interestingly enough, the book was
named the Hamidian Treatise, as a tribute to Abdul Hamid II. When the
book became popular, al-Jisr was invited by Abdul Hamid II to Istanbul and was
received in the Malta Mansion and was given the Fourth Class Order of Osmanieh,
in addition to various other gifts. Abdul Hamid II praised him on numerous
occasions. He was invited three times by Abdul Hamid II to Istanbul and stayed
as the Sultan's guest.
Abdul
Hamid II instructed the translation and publication of the Hamidian Treatise
in Turkish and asked al-Jisr to compile a book on religious principles for
schools.114
Abdul
Hamid II indeed showed support for al-Jisr but the truth was al-Jisr and his
book were among the main reasons that led to the fall of the Ottoman Empire.
Under the personal orders of Abdul Hamid II, the book was widely disseminated
across the Empire. In the book, which he dedicated to Abdul Hamid II, al-Jisr
claimed –despite the complete absence of scientific evidence to back his point-
that mutations could help organisms evolve and that there were many
transitional forms. According to al-Jisr, Darwin's theory did not contradict
the religion of Islam.
The truth
is mutations are deformations that are harmful 99% of the time and neutral the
remaining 1% time. As a matter of fact, recent scientific studies showed that
even the 1% accepted to be neutral become harmful over time. For this reason,
they are now called silent mutations. In other words, science has proven that
mutations are 100% harmful. Furthermore, the claim that 'there is a sufficient
amount of transitional forms' is one of the biggest deceptions of the theory of
evolution. More than 700 million fossils have been unearthed so far and not
even one of them belongs to a transitional form. Not even one single transitional form fossil has been found so far showing that
living things evolved from another, and it is impossible that any will be found
in the future. Each and every one of the hundreds of millions of fossils
unearthed so far belongs to complete, perfect, flawless creatures that hadn't
gone through any changes. Even Darwin himself admitted in his book that unless
transitional form fossils are found, his theory would collapse:
…why,
if species have descended from other species by fine gradations, do we not
everywhere see innumerable transitional forms? Why is not all nature in
confusion, instead of the species being, as we see them, well defined…? But, as
by this theory innumerable transitional forms must have existed, why do we not
find them embedded in countless numbers in the crust of the earth…? Why then is
not every geological formation and every stratum full of such intermediate links?
Geology assuredly does not reveal any such finely graduated organic chain; and
this, perhaps, is the most obvious and gravest objection which can be urged
against my theory.115
Al-Jisr
went as far as claiming that this theory, which denied the existence of God,
did not contradict the Qur'an. His Hamidian Treatise was full of
unscientific and non-Qur'anic explanations like the mistaken claim that
Darwin's theory did not contradict with belief in God and that theory of
evolution could be interpreted in line with religion and that some verses could
be construed that way. He provided an example of those writers and scholars of
the time, who sought to spread this lie among religious people. Indeed, his
book was translated into many languages, particularly Turkish and Urdu, and
quickly became popular among many scholars in modern Syria and Turkey. Some of
the scholars in Al-Azhar University, in particular, paid close attention to the
book. Al-Jisr was himself a graduate of that university.
Hasan
Tahsini, also known as Hoxha Tahsin, was the first rector of the Darülfünûn
–the original Istanbul University-, founded by Sultan Abdul Hamid II. Hasan
Tahsini was among the first Darwinists in the Ottoman Empire and was appointed
to the post of rector of the University by Abdul Hamid II. Grand Vizier Reşid
Pasha had personally sent him to Europe to study, from where he returned as a
materialist. In his article 'Tarih-i Tekvin' (History of Creation), he was
talking about the so-called 'new levels of change that the universe would
achieve in the future as a result of the rule of evolution that dominated the
entire universe and existence'.116
Hasan
Tahsini famously tried to explain the origin of the universe and the creation
of man as well as other life forms through the theory of evolution in his book Varoluşun
Tarihi veya Yaratılış (History of Being or Creation). He also worked
vehemently to spread the Darwinist theory. His staunch devotion to the
materialist theory earned him the nickname 'Monsieur Tahsini'. He brought Jamal
al-Din al-Afghani, an evolutionist Al-Azhar graduate, to Istanbul and allowed
him to carry out evolutionist propaganda at Istanbul University. Afghani was
another fervent supporter of al-Jisr's book. Hasan Tahsini raised many students
before he was dismissed from his duty on the grounds of 'impairing the faith of
the young people he taught'. However, many of his students now were
materialists, were already working across the Empire's lands and teaching other
young people Darwinism, which made the theory spread like wildfire.
Books and
articles of Ahmed Midhat Efendi, another evolutionist, were also widely used as
reference texts in the university. Dağarcık (Repertoire) magazine
published by Ahmed Midhat Efendi in 1871 heavily propagandized the erroneous
idea of evolution while its tens of thousands of copies were widely circulated
throughout the Empire. He claimed that 'humans had inherently violent qualities
as humans were also sort of animals' as he defended the violence of social
Darwinism as follows:
Revenge
is a sort of justice, is a violent justice. Evil is done rarely for pleasure,
but rather it is pursued for greed, reputation and interests. Then how do we
know that the evil behavior, a part of our nature, will harm us? If teazel
hurts, it's because it's created that way.117
Similarly,
the 'Ottoman Society of Science' founded by Münif Pasha, who was the Minister
of Education during the reign of Abdul Hamid II, aimed at spreading materialism
and evolution through scientific journals. Their first journal, Mecmua-i
Fünûn (Journal of Sciences) was filled with evolutionist propaganda. Sultan
Abdülaziz had previously dismissed Münif Pasha due to propagandizing evolution
but when Abdul Hamid II ascended to the throne, Münif Pasha was again made the
Minister of Education.
Darwinist
and materialist inculcation worked, with results becoming quickly visible as
the Ottoman intelligentsia began gathering around the so-called New Literature
Movement and its publication Servet-i Fünûn (Wealth of Knowledge), which
acted as the hub of materialism and positivism. Abdülhak Hamid Tarhan and
Recaizade Mahmud Ekrem, the leading poets and authors of the movement,
entertained following twisted views that would no doubt impair the moral values
of the society:
Islamic
civilization had reached the end of its lifetime.
A new
civilization rose in the West, with new thoughts, sociology and techniques.
This
civilization will, sooner or later, destroy the Ottoman Empire.
Sami
Frashëri (authored under the name of Şemseddin Sami Efendi), and Ahmed Cevdet,
the editors-in-chief of dailies Sabah (Morning) and Ikdam (Effort) respectively,
were also leading evolutionists during the reign of Abdul Hamid II. Sami
Frashëri's book Njeriu (Human Being) that he wrote in 1878, Ethem
Necdet's Tekâmül Kanunları (Laws of Development) and Celal Nuri's Tarih-i
Tedenniyat-ı Osmaniye: Mukadderat-ı Tarihiye (History of Ottoman Empire's
Decline: Dialectics of History) are only few of the Darwinist books
published during Abdul Hamid II's reign. Together with Tercüman-i Hakikat
(Interpreter of Truth) and its lead writer Ahmed Midhat Efendi, the three
major newspapers of the time were under evolutionist influence. Furthermore, Ceride-i
Havadis (Journal of News), another popular newspaper of the time, and its
lead writer Beşir Fuad also had evolutionary views. These people are usually
considered the first people to spread atheism in the Ottoman Empire. Ceride-i
Havadis (Journal of News) was published by the British journalist William
Nosworthy Churchill as the first semi-official newspaper of the Ottoman Empire.
Although from the outside it appeared as a journal of science and literature
and thus gathered the writers of the time under its roof, its true purpose was
shaping public opinion in favor of the political and economic interests of the
British. This point becomes even more interesting considering the fact that
David Urquhart, who had served as the secretary of the British embassy at
Istanbul between 1835 and 1837, reported to the Royal Family that he found the
Ottoman Empire, which had rich natural sources and a wide market, beneficial
for British interests.
With Ceride-i
Havadis, William Nosworthy Churchill tried subtly to make the Ottoman
public accept what was in favor of the British interests. Indeed, a couple of
years later, the Ottoman Empire began to meet the raw material needs of British
industry, and the sales of British products increased at the expense of Ottoman
industry. Turkish Cypriot scientist Niyazi Berkes speaks of how the situation
baffled the British and how they mocked the Ottoman statesmen for being so
gullible.118 (The statesmen of the time are
above such remarks)
Moreover,
many other publications during the era of Abdul Hamid II such as İçtihad
(The Opinion), Piyano Mecmuası (Piano Journal), Envar-ı Zeka (Light of
Intelligence), Yirminci Asırda Zeka Mecmuası (Intelligence Journal in Twentieth
Century), Güneş (Sun), Havran, Mecmua-ı Ulüm (Journal of Knowledge), Saadet
(Happiness), Afak (The Horizon) and Felsefe (Philosophy), contributed to
promulgation of the evolution lie in the Empire. Consequently, the Ottoman
society suffered a swift moral decline.
The
education system of Abdul Hamid II's reign raised many materialists that worked
to disseminate the lie of evolution. Some of them, and some from the years that
followed, and their anti-Islamic views can be listed as follows:
Ahmed
Midhat Efendi: One
of the first defenders of the theory of evolution in the Ottoman Empire.
Despite being previously removed from his duties by Sultan Abdülaziz, he was
invited back to Istanbul when Abdul Hamid II ascended to the throne. Abdul
Hamid II ordered him to found the newspaper Tercüman-ı Hakikat (Interpreter
of Truths), which became the semi-official publication of the Palace. The
newspaper was published until 1921, with famous Darwinist writers of the time
like Ahmed Cevdet and Ahmed Rasim as its regular columnists. Abdul Hamid II
also appointed Ahmed Midhat as the director of the State Publishing House.
Some of
the titles of Ahmed Midhat Efendi's pieces were, "Adem ve Orangutan"
(Adam and Orangutan), "Hayvanatın Hissi" (Feelings of Animals),
"İnsan Tenha Yaşasa Ne Olur" (What Would Happen if Humans Lived
Alone). The last-mentioned piece claimed that humans had a completely
animalistic past and that they supposedly evolved in time to reach their
current state in addition to other outlandish notions, such as if a human baby
lived among animals, he would have behaved like an animal.
Another
piece by Ahmed Midhat, "Dünyada İnsanın Zuhuru" (The Appearance of
Man on Earth) which was taught in schools, started with the following sentence:
'Since humans are sort of animals, of course we are curious how they might have
come into being in this world'. The article was full of Darwinist tales.
Another
article by Ahmed Midhat entitled "İntikam" (Revenge) - once again
taught in schools - wrongly claimed that violence was a part of human nature;
in other words, he was promoting social Darwinism:
Revenge
is a sort of justice, is a violent justice. … Then how do we know that the evil
behavior, a part of our nature, will harm us?
Mehmed
Esad Saffet Pasha: Ahmed
Midhat was a close friend of Saffet Pasha, a Minister of Education during the
rule of Abdul Hamid II. Upon orders from the Sultan, Saffet Pasha appointed
Hasan Tahsini as the rector of Istanbul University, who was another
evolutionist. He was one of the people who completely changed the Ottoman
educational system and supposedly brought European standards to education (to
put it more accurately, he incorporated Darwinism into the education system).
He was one of the founders of Galatasaray High School, one of the centers of
Darwinist education at the time. Sedat Simavi, the founder of the Hürriyet
newspaper, is Saffet Pasha's grandson. Saffet Pasha was also one of the
plotters of the coup against Sultan Abdülaziz in 1876.
Ahmed
Rıza: Supported the
'world citizen' view of positivism. Due to his anglophile character and
emulation of English style in the way he dressed, he was also known as the
English Ahmed Rıza.
Salih
Zeki: Defended the
materialist views of Auguste Comte in Robert College, Darüşşafaka and
Darülfünûn, where he lectured.
Rıza
Tevfik: Considered
Herbert Spencer and Charles Darwin as his teachers and promoted Darwinism in
his articles.
Hüseyin
Cahit Yalçın:
Became a materialist while studying at the School of Political Sciences. He
considered the theory of evolution as a requirement of materialism and rejected
Creation.
Ahmet
Şuayb: Worked as a
lecturer at the School of Law and Istanbul University, and supported the views
of Comte.
Abdullah
Cevdet: After being
introduced to evolutionist ideas at the Medical School, Abdullah Cevdet
proselytized his materialist, evolutionist and atheist views for the following
28 years through his magazine İçtihad (The Opinion). His destructive
ideas created a deep wound in Ottoman society. He was a social Darwinist that
went as far as suggesting that European men should be brought for breeding so
that Turkish race could be improved.119 According to Abdullah Cevdet, the superiority
of the races could be determined by the size of their skulls. He was a member
of the Society of the Friends of England, which was founded by anglophiles
during the occupation of Istanbul. He published Fünûn ve Felsefe
(Science and Philosophy) that sought to reconcile the ideas of Islamic scholars
with those of materialist philosophers and biologists.
A staunch
propagandist of Darwinism and atheism through his numerous articles and books,
Abdullah Cevdet was appointed to the Vienna Embassy by Abdul Hamid II. Many
people wrongly believe that Abdullah Cevdet was a dissident against the Sultan.
The truth was different however, because Abdullah Cevdet was one of the
informers working for Abdul Hamid II. Abdul Hamid II provided him with the
necessary funding so that he could settle in Vienna. Strangely enough, he was also
one of the people behind the 1908 coup that saw the deposition of Abdul Hamid
II.
Physician
Hayrullah Efendi: "İnsanın
Satıhı Arzda Sureti İntişarı" (The Spread of Man on the Face of Earth) by
Hayrullah Efendi was one of the most popular evolutionist pieces that
circulated at schools during the reign of Abdul Hamid II. He claimed that in
addition to the account of human history that started with the Prophet Adam
(pbuh), the origins of humans had to be explained from an evolutionary
perspective.
Ziya
Gökalp: A protégé
of Abdullah Cevdet, Gökalp spread materialist views in Turkish society and
played a big role in the moral decline that affected a large part of the
community.
Süleyman
Hüsnü Pasha:
Commander of the military college and one of the coup plotters that organized
the deposing of Sultan Abdülaziz.
Süleyman
Pashazade Sami: The
son of the coup plotter Süleyman Hüsnü Pasha, he served as the Minister of
Education and as the rector of the Istanbul University. He prepared guidelines
for primary schools, and worked on children's education with a project named
'Education and Training of Children'.
Beşir
Fuad: Had a
materialist worldview. As the mentor of Abdullah Cevdet, Baha Tevfik, Ahmet
Nebil and Celal Nuri, he was responsible for their materialist views. He
introduced social Darwinism to the Ottoman Empire, which was one of the basic
ideologies of Young Turks during the Abdul Hamid II rule. Beşir Fuad was
heavily influenced by evolutionist/materialist thinkers such as Claude Bernard
and Ludwig Büchner. He committed suicide at the age of 35 and wrote down how he
felt as he slipped away. He said that he did this to leave a scientific
understanding as to what one feels at time of death. This suicide created shock
waves in the Ottoman society, which up to that point was quite unfamiliar with
the concept of suicide, and triggered a suicide trend in Istanbul.
Baha
Tevfik: Became an
evolutionist at the School of Political Sciences during the reign of Abdul
Hamid II. He argued for unconditional Westernization. In an article he wrote
for the journal Felsefe (Philosophy), he claimed that a philosopher had
to be a scientist and definitely a materialist. To him metaphysics was 'empty
and negative' and contradicted science. In his book Hassasiyet Bahsi ve
Yeni Ahlak (Issue of Sensitivities and New Morality), he rejected religious
moral values. His so-called solution for the future of the humanity was
communism and anarchy. He believed that the future could be revived with
scientific anarchy.
Hüseyin
Hilmi: It is
reported that he got his communist ideals from Baha Tevfik. In the journal
İştirak (The Participation) that he published in 1910, he wrote several
pieces on Marxism.
Subhi
Edhem: A teacher of
history of nature, he was also an author at Servet-i Fünun (Wealth of
Knowledge). Taught Lamarckism and Darwinism during his lectures.
Ethem
Nejat: Became an
evolutionist together with Baha Tevfik. He was also writing for İçtihad (The
Opinion) magazine of Abdullah Cevdet. He was the founding general secretary
of the Communist Party of Turkey.
Memduh
Süleyman:
Translated Eduard von Hartmann's book Wahrheit und Irrtum im Darwinismus, and
co-authored Nietzsche'nin Hayatı ve Felsefesi (Nietzsche's Life and
Philosophy) with Baha Tevfik. He was one of the ideologues of Ottoman
Socialist Party.
Celal
Nuri İleri: Believed
that matter didn't have a beginning or an end. After reading Jacques-Bénigne
Bossuet's Discours sur l'histoire universelle (Discourse on Universal
History), he became an evolutionist and argued in his book Tarih-i
İstikbal (History of Future) (1915) that Islam should be reformed by means
of materialism and evolution. According to Celal Nuri, matter was everywhere,
every moment and could not have possibly gone bad. He believed that power was
an inherent part of matter, that the two were interlinked and could not be
separated. He made a feeble attempt to reconcile Islam and the theory of
evolution. The truth is, he rejected belief in God right in the beginning of
his book, making his intentions clear that, as an evolutionist, he was only
trying to spread an atheistic ideology in the Empire.